In Praise of the Archbishop of Doubt

In a click-obsessed world it’s not surprising that the archbishop of Canterbury, the Most Rev. Justin Welby, drew some gasping headlines last week.

Welby’s comments occurred during a BBC interview in Bristol Diocese in which the reporter asked, “Do you ever doubt?” Welby responded,

Yes. I do. In lots of different ways, really.” After gathering his thoughts, Welby said,

 It is a really good question. … The other day I was praying over something as I was running, and I ended up saying to God, ‘Look, this is all very well, but isn’t it about time you did something, if you’re there?’ Which is probably not what the archbishop of Canterbury should say.

But it is what the archbishop should say. I quite appreciated Julia Baird’s Op-Ed in the NY Times last week, “Doubt as a Sign of Faith” in which Baird reminds readers of the commonality of doubt in the Christian tradition from the day one.

Sure, there’s Job, and the Psalms, and the disciples. But there’s also Calvin, and C.S. Lewis, Mother Teresa, and Flannery O’Connor, to name a few.

Prayer is the LanguageFor me, the truly noteworthy story would have had Welby respond, “No, never have I ever doubted.” As Baird points out, “the philosopher Bertrand Russell put it best. The whole problem with the world, he wrote, is that ‘the stupid are cocksure while the intelligent are full of doubt.’”

For a PhD course on creativity I’m taking, I’m constructing a set of 52 “Spirituality Cards,” notecards with spiritual quotes, experiences, and influences on them (my decorating is atrocious, by the way). The description of the project includes filling ten cards with examples of “…a spiritual experience or answered prayer.” I filled all ten with spiritual experiences.

The project helped me again realize my reticence to approach faith as something as simple as “Ask a question, get an answer.” Prayer is practice, seeking, life-changing, question-asking, but for me rarely about a fill-in-the-blank response from God. For me, speaking of “answered prayer” misses the point.

If we approach faith and religion as only something of intellectual assent, like some ultimate scientific experiment to prove God’s good existence now and forever, then it’s a shock that a world faith leader would admit doubt. But that’s not what faith is about.

And so we need reporters, pastors, believers, and doubters everywhere to lower the heat of the public faith conversation. We need to share these honest age-old truths about faith without worry of the tweets that will follow. Our faith demands it. No doubt about it.

image by Leland Francisco

Dreaming of an Artists’ Pub (in Fargo)

Reflections on my search (in vain) for a true artists’ pub in Fargo.


Choosing What’s Best for College

As college begins, student faces hundreds of new choices. But what if we opened ourselves to the uncomfortable notion that you don’t always have to choose. Life’s moments have a funny way of choosing you.


Sabbath for Professors…and Students?

As the school year begins, I’m considering an “email Sabbath” clause for my syllabi. But does that mean students, too, should take a day to rest?


Sundry Summer Celebrations

I’m not sure what constitutes the official “end of summer” these days, but I think it’s here for me. Faculty workshops have replaced writing time. Syllabus prep has replaced reading time. New, longer lists of to-dos have replaced my unfinished lists of summer projects. Ready or not, it’s back to school…


Religion & Social Change: Imagining Experiential Learning

Have you had a positive (or negative) experience with service learning, and/or community-based writing assignments? What should I consider as my religion and social change course planning begins?


Can a Church Split Truly Be Gracious?

I’m grateful to report that Religion Dispatches published an essay of mine! In the piece, “Can a Church Split Truly Be Gracious?” I describe and reflect upon my experience leading a commission (officially a “Presbytery Engagement Team”) to investigate a church seeking to leave my presbytery, the Presbytery of Northern Plains. The process was fraught, troubling, and yet […]


Visualizing Recent PC(USA) Sexuality & Marriage Decisions

Have you ever wondered: what would happen if I built a digital representation of important PC(USA) ordination stands, sexuality, and marriage votes from 1996 forward? Of course, not. That’s ridiculous. What sort of nerdy, tech-curious, Presbyterian pastor and professor-type would want to do such a thing? Ummm…. Ok, well, this summer I did [click here now to jump […]


“Hannah, Delivered” a review

Hannah, Delivered is a fine new novel by Elizabeth Jarrett Andrew. Elizabeth and I met two summers ago at the Collegeville Institute, and re-met last spring at the Festival of Faith and Writing at Calvin College. When I received my copy, Elizabeth included a kind note that read, in part,“I’d love for Hannah to speak […]